Holding with or without a tax group: what is the difference?
Without a tax group, each company pays tax on its own profit. The subsidiary distributes a dividend, and the holding pays tax on 5 % of it. With a corporate income tax group (Organschaft), the subsidiary's income is attributed to the controlling company: profits and losses of the companies offset each other, but a profit transfer agreement binds both for at least five years.
| Question | Without a tax group | With a tax group |
|---|---|---|
| What is required? | The shareholding. Dividends follow the subsidiary's resolution on the appropriation of profit. | A profit transfer agreement for at least five years that is actually carried out for that time, and the majority of the voting rights in the subsidiary from the start of its financial year (§ 14 (1) no. 1 and 3 KStG). |
| How is the subsidiary's profit taxed? | The subsidiary pays corporate income tax and trade tax. At the holding, 95 % of its dividend stays tax-free; 5 % count as non-deductible expenses (§ 8b (1) and (5) KStG). | The subsidiary's income is attributed to the controlling company and taxed there (§ 14 (1) KStG). For trade tax, the subsidiary counts as a permanent establishment of the controlling company (§ 2 (2) sentence 2 GewStG). |
| What happens to the subsidiary's losses? | They stay with the subsidiary and only reduce its own income. | They reduce the income attributed to the controlling company. The controlling company must make good every annual net loss of the subsidiary (§ 302 AktG; for a GmbH as subsidiary the agreement must refer to it, § 17 (1) sentence 2 no. 2 KStG). |
| How long are you bound? | Not at all. | At least five years. Ending it earlier is only harmless if terminated for good cause (§ 14 (1) no. 3 KStG). |
| And VAT? | Each company files its own advance VAT return; invoices between them carry VAT. | The VAT group has its own conditions and needs no agreement: the subsidiary must be financially, economically and organisationally integrated into the controlling company's business. Supplies between them are then internal, and the controlling company files for all (§ 2 (2) no. 2 UStG). |
| What does ZepDesk do? | Keeps the shareholdings as master data and shows the reconciliation under § 8b KStG for every investment income. Shareholdings | Connects two ZepDesk companies, compiles the group's advance VAT return and trade income and books the transfer up to the maximum under § 301 AktG. Setting up a tax group |
Worked example: a subsidiary profit of €100,000
The subsidiary pays €15,000 corporate income tax, €825 solidarity surcharge and, at a municipal multiplier of 400 %, €14,000 trade tax, €29,825 in total. If it distributes the remaining €70,175, 5 % of that counts as non-deductible at the holding, i.e. €3,508.75. On this the holding pays €526.31 corporate income tax, €28.95 solidarity surcharge and €491.23 trade tax, €1,046.49 in total. For trade tax the dividend itself is deducted, but the 5 % stays in trade income (§ 9 no. 2a sentence 4 GewStG).
| Tax | without a tax group | with a tax group |
|---|---|---|
| at the subsidiary: corporate income tax, solidarity surcharge, trade tax | 29,825.00 | 0.00 |
| at the holding, on the subsidiary's profit | 1,046.49 | 29,825.00 |
| total | 30,871.49 | 29,825.00 |
Here the tax group saves €1,046.49, about 1 % of the profit. It saves more when one company makes losses and another makes profits. Against that stand the agreement, the duty to take over the subsidiary's losses and five years of commitment. Which form suits you is a question for your tax adviser.
Sources, in German: § 14, § 17, § 8b and § 23 KStG, § 4 SolZG, § 2, § 9 and § 11 GewStG, § 302 AktG, § 2 UStG. As of 14 November 2026. This overview does not replace tax advice.
How a group is set up in ZepDesk
Every company gets a company of its own with its own address, such as muster-holding.zepdesk.de, its own database, its own chart of accounts, its own tax profile and its own letterhead. No other company sees its postings.
How are dividends to a holding company taxed in Germany?
For a holding GmbH, 95 % of the dividends from its corporations stay tax-free: they are disregarded, and 5 % count as non-deductible expenses (§ 8b (1) and (5) KStG). This requires a direct shareholding of at least 10 % at the start of the calendar year; acquiring at least 10 % in one go during the year counts as held from the start. Below that the dividend is fully taxable ((4)). For trade tax the dividend is only deducted if the shareholding was at least 15 % at the start of the assessment period (§ 9 no. 2a GewStG); otherwise it is added back (§ 8 no. 5 GewStG).
If the holding sells shares in a corporation, 95 % of the gain also stays tax-free, with no minimum shareholding (§ 8b (2) and (3) KStG). The gain stays taxable to the extent the shares were previously written down with tax effect ((2) sentence 4). Excluded for dividends and sales alike are shares in the trading book of banks, investment firms and financial services institutions, shares held as current assets by certain financial enterprises, and shares in the investments of life and health insurers ((7) and (8)).
In ZepDesk: A holding does not need a tax group to work in ZepDesk. It keeps its shareholdings as master data: investee, share today and on 1 January, acquisition date, acquisition cost, book value and accounts. It records every income item from a shareholding with its type and gross amount. ZepDesk shows the reconciliation under § 8b KStG and the treatment for trade tax. You post the income itself in the journal and mark the participation income as posted.
Without a tax group, no figures flow between the companies. The holding records the subsidiary's dividend itself, with the amount from the profit appropriation resolution.
| Shareholding | Share on 1 Jan | Gross dividend | Tax-free under § 8b (1) | Remains in income | In trade income | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Muster Technik GmbH | 100 % | 40,000 | 38,000 | 2,000 | 2,000 | 5 % count as non-deductible expenses (§ 8b (5) KStG); reduction under § 9 no. 2a GewStG from 15 % |
| Shareholding B | 12 % | 10,000 | 9,500 | 500 | 10,000 | added back under § 8 no. 5 GewStG, because below 15 % |
| Shareholding C | 5 % | 1,000 | 0 | 1,000 | 1,000 | free float below 10 %, fully taxable (§ 8b (4) KStG) |
ZepDesk produces the corporate tax return with income from shareholdings as an ELSTER file, including lines 151 to 201 of annex GK; the tax number of the distributing company is not required there. Annex BEG of the trade tax return requires it for a German company; you enter the tax number and federal state on the shareholding. No file is produced for a write-up on a shareholding (corporate tax) or for a foreign shareholding (trade tax, § 9 no. 7 GewStG); ZepDesk then states the reason.
Sources, in German: § 8b KStG, § 8 and § 9 GewStG. As of 14 November 2026. This overview does not replace tax advice.
How do I set up a tax group in ZepDesk?
A tax group links two ZepDesk companies. You set it up under Company, Tax group, in the controlling company or in the subsidiary. When you register a further company, the checkbox “Belongs to the group of the main company (Organschaft)” does this; it only sends the request, the subsidiary has to consent itself.
- The administration of either company enters the other's ZepDesk address, such as muster-technik.zepdesk.de. If the subsidiary sends the request, it is asking to be admitted itself.
- The other side's administration decides: the subsidiary consents, or the controlling company confirms the admission. A request is valid for 72 hours.
- The controlling company enters which kinds of tax group apply, for VAT, corporate tax or trade tax, each with a start and an end. The subsidiary sees the details; only the controlling company can change them.
- The controlling company retrieves the subsidiary's key figures for every period in which the matching kind applies. Every retrieval is recorded in the subsidiary's change log.
- Either side can end the tax group. After that the controlling company only retrieves the advance VAT return, trade income and consolidation figures, only for the time up to the end and for at most 18 months, until its last returns have been filed.
What ZepDesk does with it for each tax
| Tax | What ZepDesk does | What stays with you |
|---|---|---|
| VAT | Compiles the advance VAT return of the whole tax group at the controlling company, across all tiers. Intra-group sales drop out on both sides: the outgoing side from the tax base and the tax, the incoming side from input VAT. They are recognised when the other company's ZepDesk address is stored with the customer or supplier. A controlled company's own advance return is blocked. | The checked file of the controlling company's advance return contains the whole tax group. If a subsidiary has not answered, ZepDesk blocks filing and names the company and the reason. |
| Trade tax | Compiles the trade income of the tax group, with each company's contribution shown separately. An allowance counts at most once, and only if the controlling company is not a corporation; the tax base amount follows from that. | The controlling company's trade tax return is produced as a file, with the name, trade income and, if entered, tax number of each controlled company (lines 105 to 109); you enter trade income and tax number in the return. If the tax group starts or ends during the assessment period or has several tiers, ZepDesk does not calculate the apportionment and no file is produced. Each controlled company files its own return (§ 14a GewStG). |
| Corporate tax | Posts the profit transfer per controlled company on your instruction, at most up to the amount under § 301 AktG, and reverses it within the same financial year if you instruct it to. Retrieves the subsidiary's taxable result. ZepDesk shows the controlled company's income from shareholdings gross; § 8b KStG is applied only by the controlling company. | The corporate tax returns with annexes OG and OT are produced as ELSTER files: the controlled company's income stays at zero, and the controlling company adds it through annex OT. You enter the income to be attributed and the tax number of each controlled company at the controlling company. When no file is produced is listed under What ZepDesk does not take on. |
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Net income for the year before the transfer | 180,000 |
| less loss carried forward from the previous year | 30,000 |
| less transfer to the statutory reserve, none for a GmbH | 0 |
| less amount blocked from distribution under § 268 (8) HGB | 15,000 |
| Maximum profit transfer | 135,000 |
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Contribution of Muster Holding GmbH | 10,000 |
| Contribution of Muster Technik GmbH | 150,000 |
| Contribution of Muster Service GmbH | 40,000 |
| Allowance, the controlling company is a GmbH | 0 |
| Trade income of the tax grouptax base amount 3.5 %: 7,000 | 200,000 |
If the controlling company were a sole proprietorship, ZepDesk would deduct the allowance of €24,500 once from the trade income of the tax group: €175,500 × 3.5 % = €6,142.50.
Worked example: the advance VAT return of a tax group
Three companies, one advance return at the controlling company. The second-tier subsidiary sits below the subsidiary, and ZepDesk queries both tiers. Example from a demo group; all companies and amounts are fictitious.
| Company | Sales at 19 % (Kz 81) | VAT | Input VAT (Kz 66) | VAT payable | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Muster Holding GmbHcontrolling company | 12,000.00 | 2,280.00 | 950.00 | 1,330.00 | |
| Muster Technik GmbHcontrolled company, subsidiary | 59,900.00 | 11,381.00 | 4,465.00 | 6,916.00 | |
| Muster Service GmbHcontrolled company of Technik, second tier | 6,800.00 | 1,292.00 | 42.00 | 1,250.00 | |
| Tax groupone return at the controlling company | 78,700.00 | 14,953.00 | 5,457.00 | 9,496.00 |
Checked: 78,700.00 × 19 % = 14,953.00 and 1,330.00 + 6,916.00 + 1,250.00 = 9,496.00. Technik and Service do not file a return of their own.

What applies to invoices and loans between group companies?
You charge services between the holding and its subsidiaries, such as management, rent or a loan, as you would charge an outside customer, on terms that independent third parties would also agree. If a subsidiary grants its shareholder a benefit caused by the shareholder relationship, for example through an excessive price, that is a hidden profit distribution (verdeckte Gewinnausschüttung); it does not reduce the subsidiary's income (§ 8 (3) sentence 2 KStG, R 8.5 (1) KStR). If the holding controls the subsidiary, the tax authorities usually assume this already when a clear agreement on service and payment made in advance is missing or not followed (R 8.5 (2) KStR). For dealings with related parties abroad, § 1 AStG expressly requires the arm's length principle.
For VAT it depends on the tax group. Without one, the invoice to the sister company is an ordinary invoice with VAT. Within a VAT group, supplies between the companies are internal; the group counts as one business (§ 2 (2) no. 2 UStG).
You write it in ZepDesk like any other invoice; the other company records it as an incoming invoice. Each company keeps its own books.
If the other company's ZepDesk address is stored on the customer or supplier, ZepDesk removes these sales from the group's advance VAT return: outgoing ones from the tax base and the tax, incoming ones from the input VAT.
ZepDesk does not match loans and clearing accounts between the companies, and it does not check whether a price is at arm's length. That stays with you and your tax adviser.
Sources, in German: § 8 KStG, R 8.5 KStR 2022, § 1 AStG, § 2 UStG. As of 14 November 2026. This overview does not replace tax advice. How a GmbH pays out a dividend is under GmbH and UG.
Does a holding company have to prepare consolidated financial statements?
If the holding is a corporation or a GmbH & Co. KG and can exercise a controlling influence over a subsidiary, for example through the majority of the voting rights, it prepares consolidated financial statements and a group management report within the first five months of the financial year, a capital market oriented holding within the first four months (§ 290 (1) HGB, § 264a HGB). It is exempt if on two consecutive balance sheet dates two of three figures are not exceeded each time: combined €30m total assets, €60m revenue and 250 employees on annual average, or after consolidation €25m, €50m and 250 employees (§ 293 (1) HGB). The exemption does not apply if the holding or a subsidiary to be included is capital market oriented or is subject to special rules as a credit institution, financial services firm, insurer or pension fund (§ 293 (5) HGB). An intermediate holding needs no consolidated statements of its own if its parent based in the EU or EEA prepares consolidated statements that meet the requirements of § 291 HGB.
In ZepDesk: ZepDesk first checks the size-based exemption under § 293 HGB, using the gross method on two consecutive balance sheet dates. ZepDesk does not calculate the net method. If one of the three figures is missing, the answer stays open. The figures are only compiled for a corporate tax group; if the holding only holds shareholdings, ZepDesk names them and says that consolidated financial statements need to be checked.
The compilation contains the totals of the individual financial statements, intra-group sales under § 305 HGB, the offsetting difference under § 303 HGB and a proposal for the scope of consolidation. Capital consolidation (§ 301 HGB), elimination of intra-group profits (§ 304 HGB) and uniform valuation (§ 308 HGB) are explicitly marked as open. More on the individual company's accounts is under Annual financial statements.
Sources, in German: § 290, § 291, § 293 and § 264a HGB. As of 14 November 2026. This overview does not replace tax advice.
What a group costs
The tax group is not an add-on module. Every company is a company of its own and costs the monthly price of its legal form.
Each company at the rate of its own legal form, no group discount. This applies to the first company as to every further one. If you pay yearly, you pay 10 monthly amounts for twelve months.
Muster Holding GmbH, Muster Technik GmbH and Muster Service GmbH, three corporations at €79 each: €237 per month, or €2,370 per year if paid yearly.
Plus Muster Besitz GbR as a partnership at €49: €286 per month, or €2,860 per year if paid yearly.
What ZepDesk does not take on
Both companies need a company of their own in ZepDesk. A company outside ZepDesk cannot be linked.
Whether a tax group exists for tax purposes depends on the profit transfer agreement, its performance and the integration. ZepDesk calculates with the kinds and periods your administration enters.
ZepDesk does not calculate multi-tier tax groups, a start or end during the financial year, outside shareholders, a hidden profit distribution by the controlled company, a net income remaining after the transfer (reserves, excess and shortfall transfers) or the interest barrier from three million euros of net interest expense. In these cases no file is produced, and ZepDesk states the reason.
ZepDesk does not take on capital consolidation, elimination of intra-group profits or uniform valuation.
Reports exist per company; to compare, you switch with the company switcher.
Each company posts loans, clearing accounts and services between the companies on its own.
Questions about groups
Do I need a tax group to run several companies?
No. Every company is a company of its own, and one sign-in covers them all. A holding without a tax group keeps its shareholdings as master data and records dividends itself, with the reconciliation under § 8b KStG.
Does the holding see the subsidiary's books?
Only if someone from the holding has a role in the subsidiary, such as Read-only. Through the tax group the controlling company receives no receipts, invoices, customers or suppliers, only key figures; of postings and accounts only the posted profit transfer and the income account of each shareholding. Every retrieval is recorded in the subsidiary's change log.
From what shareholding are dividends tax-free for the holding?
For corporate income tax, from a direct shareholding of 10 % at the start of the calendar year; then 95 % of the dividend stays tax-free (§ 8b (1), (4) and (5) KStG). For trade tax the deduction only applies from 15 % at the start of the assessment period (§ 9 no. 2a GewStG). A worked example is under dividends to a holding.
How long must a profit transfer agreement run?
At least five years, and it must actually be carried out for that time. Ending it earlier is only harmless if it is terminated for good cause (§ 14 (1) no. 3 KStG). You conclude the agreement itself outside ZepDesk; ZepDesk calculates with the types and periods your administration enters.
Which legal forms can form a tax group?
Only a corporation can be the controlled company for corporate income and trade tax: GmbH, UG, AG, SE or KGaA (§§ 14 and 17 KStG, § 2 (2) sentence 2 GewStG). The controlling company can be a commercial business, including a sole proprietorship; a partnership only if it is commercially active itself (§ 14 (1) sentence 1 no. 2 KStG). For VAT, the tax authorities also accept a partnership as a controlled company if, besides the controlling company, its only partners are persons who are themselves financially integrated into its business (section 2.8 (5a) UStAE, in German). ZepDesk therefore allows partnerships and the eG as controlled companies for VAT; you check the condition on the partners yourself. ZepDesk does not provide a tax group for freelancers as individuals or for associations and foundations.
Does our group have to prepare consolidated financial statements?
§ 293 HGB governs this. ZepDesk checks the exemption using the gross method on two consecutive balance sheet dates; ZepDesk does not calculate the net method. If one of the three figures is missing, the answer stays open instead of assuming an exemption. The check reads the scope of consolidation from the corporate tax groups that the controlling company has entered. Without them ZepDesk only names the shareholdings or tax groups that suggest a subsidiary and says that consolidated financial statements need to be checked; it then makes no statement on the size exemption.
What does a group cost?
Every company costs the monthly price of its legal form; there is no group discount. A holding with a subsidiary and a second-tier subsidiary, all three GmbH, costs €237 per month. The worked example is above under What a group costs.
Set up your group in ZepDesk.
Every company becomes a company of its own. If you move from other software, each company moves separately, ideally as of the same date; how that works is under Switching from other software. What your group costs per month is worked out by the group calculator on the pricing page.